Chicago Bankruptcy

Archive for the ‘ Bankruptcy ’ Category

Bankruptcy And Student Loans: A Primer

Posted on: October 16, 2017 by in Bankruptcy, student debt
No Comments

Although student loans are unsecured debts, like credit cards, Small Business Administration loans, and medical bills, they are not automatically dischargeable like these other obligations. In fact, several years ago, Congress even closed the private student loan loophole, which is bad news for former ITT Tech students and other similarly situated borrowers.

There is an old saying among attorneys that “bad facts make bad law,” and that’s certainly the case in this regard, when closely examining the landmark decision Brunner v. New York State Higher Education Services.

The Brunner Rule

About ten years before the Second Circuit in New York decided this case, federal lawmakers rewrote the Bankruptcy Code, and there was considerable controversy about the student loan provision. Previously, such debts were automatically dischargeable. But there was some concern that student protesters in the 1960s borrowed their way through school and then adamantly refused to repay their loans.

Whether that was true or not, Congress included a provision that student loans could be discharged only upon showing of “undue hardship,” but lawmakers left it up to the courts to define that phrase.

Along came Marie Brunner, who graduated with a master’s degree in social work and had no apparent problems finding employment. Almost immediately thereafter, she asked a bankruptcy judge to discharge her debt, despite the fact that she had made no payments and had never asked for any other lesser kind of relief, such as a temporary forbearance.

In response, the appeals court endorsed what soon became known as the Brunner rule. It stated that student loans could be discharged in bankruptcy only if the debtor:

  • – Had made a good faith effort to repay the loan,
  • – Suffered from a long term disability, and
  • – Could not maintain a minimal standard of living if forced to repay the debt.

At first blush, the Brunner rule seems impossible to meet, since the elements of the test seem inconsistent, viz, if one cannot maintain a minimal standard of living, how can one make a good faith repayment effort? As a result only about .01 percent of consumer bankruptcy petitions even ask for a student loan discharge.

Meeting the Brunner Rule

Yet according to this same survey, about 40 percent of debtors who ask for student loan relief receive at least a partial discharge.

One factor in the debtor’s favor is that student loan debt is much, much higher now than it was forty years ago. Many people, especially those with graduate degrees, owe $40,000 or more, and it is a lot harder to pay off that amount of debt as opposed to $15,000 or $20,000.

As for the “minimal standard of living” prong, it’s generally understood that this level is akin to the poverty line, but there is a big difference between “generally understood” and black-letter law. If the debtor has to put off major purchases because of the student loan, some judges may be sympathetic and allow at least a partial discharge.

There’s another old saying in the law that “you don’t get anything unless you ask,” and in these cases, it may be worth asking for student loan discharge.

Connect With Experienced Attorneys

Student loan discharge is difficult, but not impossible, in consumer bankruptcy cases. For a free consultation with an experienced bankruptcy attorney in Chicago, contact the Bentz Holguin Law Firm, LLC. We aggressively represent student loan borrowers.

Resource:

leagle.com/decision/19871226831f2d39511143

Four Dischargeable Debts In Bankruptcy

Posted on: October 9, 2017 by in Bankruptcy, chapter 13, chapter 7
No Comments

The end result of a bankruptcy petition, in almost all cases, is a fresh financial start for the honest yet unfortunate debtor. To get this fresh start, the bankruptcy judge will discharge (legally forgive) many different kinds of debts.

Sometimes, debtors want to pay what they owe, or at least most of it, but they lack the means to do so. Such repayment is an option in both Chapter 7 and Chapter 13 cases, because even if the debt is legally discharged, the moneylender will almost always still accept payments.

Credit Cards

The math is very simple. Since 2003, wages have increased by 28 percent and prices on many items have increased between 35 and 55 percent. Something has to fill in the gap, and in most cases, that something is borrowing money on credit cards. In fact, the average credit card-holding household has account balances over $16,000 in revolving debt alone.

There is no doubt that poor financial planning and overspending account for some of this debt, but unexpected emergencies, such as medical bills and unemployment, account for a lot more.

Since there is no security agreement, credit card debt is dischargeable in both Chapter 7 and Chapter 13 cases. In addition, because of the automatic stay, moneylenders cannot pursue any adverse actions, such as lawsuits, while the case is pending.

Medical Bills

As most people might expect, medical bills have increased more than most other types of expenses over the past fifteen years, and even if the debtor has good medical insurance, the membership fees, copays, and deductibles are often financially debilitating.

Legally, medical bills fall into the same category as credit cards and so they are completely dischargeable.

Signature Loans

Small Business Administration and other bank loans, as well as payday and other nonbank loans, are also unsecured, even if the lender required bank account information or if the debtor agreed to a certain withdrawal on a certain day.

Student loans, whether or not a governmental unit guaranteed them, are only dischargeable if the debtor establishes undue hardship, and admittedly, that is not an easy showing to make in court.

Taxes

Somewhat similarly, income taxes, as opposed to payroll and other kinds of taxes, are dischargeable only under limited circumstance, but the showing is a little easier to make because it is based on time as opposed to other circumstances. The rules for both the IRS and state taxing authorities are:

  • Tax must be at least three years old,
  • Returns have been on file for the past two years, and
  • The authority has not assessed the debt in the last 240 days, which usually means that the taxpayer has not received a notice or bill in that time period.

The IRS, as well as states, are very particular on dates, and it is not unusual to see opposition based on one or two days off the deadlines.

If the taxing authority placed a lien on the taxpayer’s assets, such liens remain, because the bankruptcy judge has limited powers.

Contact Experienced Attorneys

Most debts are dischargeable in bankruptcy. For a free consultation with an experienced bankruptcy attorney in Chicago, contact the Bentz Holguin Law Firm, LLC. We handle cases in both Illinois and Indiana.

Resource:

nerdwallet.com/blog/average-credit-card-debt-household/

Exempting Houses And Cars In Illinois Bankruptcies

Posted on: October 2, 2017 by in Bankruptcy, chapter 13, chapter 7
No Comments

Whether the voluntary petition is filed under Chapter 7 or Chapter 13, most all common consumer assets are exempt in Illinois, meaning that debtors rarely, if ever, must forcibly surrender their property to the bankruptcy trustee (person who oversees the case for the judge).

Bankruptcy protects assets to help fulfill the law’s mission of a fresh financial start for “honest yet unfortunate” debtors. If Illinois filers lost their houses, cars, and other important assets, they would go back behind the starting line, an outcome that’s clearly not contemplated by the Bankruptcy Code.

All that being said, if the asset is secured by a mortgage or other loan, the debtor must keep making payments as originally agreed, at least in most cases.

House

Up to $15,000 in equity for a single filer ($30,000) for joint filers) is exempt under 750 ILCS 65-22.

Per the Bankruptcy Code, the debtor must declare the house’s as-is cash value, which may be substantially lower than the fair market value, because cash-paying home investors usually pay a maximum 60 cents on the dollar.

Although the value difference makes no difference in the amount of equity, as that figure remains the same regardless of the home’s value, the distinction makes a tremendous difference in terms of the loan-to-value ratio. Assume a single filer has a $200,000 home with $20,000 in equity and a $180,000 loan balance. Given those facts, the trustee could theoretically force the debtor to sell the house for the $5,000 in unexempt equity, although the judge would have to approve such a plan.

But the as-is cash value of that house may be as low as $100,000, meaning that the debtor is upside-down on the residence and there will be no sale.

There are some other loan-to-value issues related to exempt homesteads as well, including:

  • – Lien Strip: If the property’s value is too low to secure a second mortgage or other junior lien, the bankruptcy court may declare it to be unsecured, thus freeing the debtor from the obligations to make payments on that debt.
  • – Cram Down: In some cases, the outstanding loan balance can be reduced to match the property’s fair market or as-is value.

These options, and specifically a cram down, may be available for other assets as well, such as motor vehicle loans.

Cars

$2,400 in equity for a single filer ($4,800) for joint filers is exempt under 735 ILCS 5/12-1001(c). Typically, newer cars have almost no equity because the outstanding loan balance is so high, and older vehicles have almost no equity because they have almost no value.Once again, the debtor must declare the as-is cash value, which can be readily obtained from a site like kbb.com.

In addition to the cram down mentioned above, redemption may be an option as well, especially in longer lasting Chapter 13 cases. If the debtor pays the full fair market value of the collateral, the moneylender may be unable to collect the remaining balance on the loan, no matter how high it is.

Count On Experienced Attorneys

Nearly all bankruptcy debtors get to keep their houses, cars, and other key assets. For a free consultation with an experienced bankruptcy attorney in Chicago, contact the Bentz Holguin Law Firm, LLC. Convenient payment plans are available.

Resource:

ilga.gov/legislation/ilcs/ilcs3.asp?ActID=2102&ChapterID=59

What’s The Difference Between Chapter 7 And Chapter 13?

Posted on: September 25, 2017 by in Bankruptcy, chapter 13, chapter 7
No Comments

A number of times over the last hundred years, and perhaps most recently in 1998, the Supreme Court has reaffirmed that the purpose of the Bankruptcy Code is to give the “honest but unfortunate debtor” a fresh start. There is only one kind of honest, but there are several kinds of misfortune, which is why there are basically two types of bankruptcy.

The most successful bankruptcy debtors either are victims of unforeseeable, and usually once in a lifetime, financial storms, or they understand the mistakes they made and are committed to doing better. Many times, there is a little bit of both, as the debtor may have had an unhealthy financial habit or two that created a vulnerability to job loss, divorce, medical bills, or another unexpected event.

Chapter 7

If the debtor has mostly unsecured debts, which are credit cards and other debts that the debtor has promised to repay, an ill-named liquidation bankruptcy may be the best option. This nickname is inaccurate because, in most cases, Chapter 7 debtors do not lose any of their assets. By law, Indiana and Illinois debtors can keep their:

  • – Retirement Accounts: If the IRA, 401k, or other nest egg was earned and not inherited, the debtor can keep the entire amount, regardless of the account balance.
  • – House: Both Illinois and Indiana use value-based exemptions that protect a certain amount of home equity in a primary residence. Bear in mind that if the house is worth $200,000 and the debtor still owes $190,000, the exemption only needs to protect the $10,000 in equity.
  • – Cars: The same rule applies for motor vehicles, and generally, new cars have almost no equity and used cars have almost no value.
  • – Personal Property: Other personal property, including cash in many cases, is also exempt.

To determine value, the debtor must declare the as-is cash value (“garage sale”) value. This amount is usually much lower than the fair market value.

About six weeks after the debtor files a petition and schedules, the trustee (person who oversees the bankruptcy on behalf of the judge) reviews the paperwork to ensure that everything is in order, and about six months later, all unsecured debts are discharged.

Chapter 13

Other debtors have issues with secured debts, such as home mortgages and vehicle loans. In these cases, the debtor probably does not want the debt to disappear, because that would mean losing the secured asset. So, the wage earner plan is probably a better option. Chapter 13 debtors have up to five years to catch up on secured debts, and during the entire period, they are under the protection of the bankruptcy court. So, in most cases, moneylenders cannot take any adverse action during this time, and that includes anything from harassing phone calls to repossession.

During the trustee meeting, the debtor and trustee come up with an income-based repayment plan, which is nearly always a better alternative to the debt-based “repayment plans” that moneylenders offer.

Debtors can voluntarily convert their plans from Chapter 13 to Chapter 7, and vice versa, at almost any time. So, many debtors file a Chapter 13, and if they find they cannot afford the debt consolidation payments, they convert to Chapter 7, wrap things up quickly, and take full advantage of their fresh starts.

Go With Experienced Attorneys

Different distressed debtors have different legal options in bankruptcy. For a free consultation with an experienced bankruptcy attorney in Chicago, contact the Bentz Holguin Law Firm, LLC. Our attorneys are licensed in both Illinois and Indiana.

Resource:

scholar.google.com/scholar_case?case=583609839906134327&hl=en&as_sdt=6&as_vis=1&oi=scholarr

A.D.K. Arms Files Bankruptcy

Posted on: September 19, 2017 by in Bankruptcy
No Comments

Aggressive debt collection tactics may have forced the firearms manufacturer into bankruptcy. Do ordinary people file bankruptcy for the same reason?

A.D.K. and its affiliate company, Advanced Precision Manufacturing, Inc., sought Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection almost simultaneously, apparently because Midwest Community Bank was attempting to collect on a $3.9 million loan and the company either could not, or would not, satisfy that obligation. Indeed, A.D.K. also filed a civil suit against the bank, alleging unfair debt collection practices.

Many companies use Chapter 11 to reorganize under the protection of a federal court.

Bankruptcy and Debt Collection

Over the past several years, many large banks have acquired many smaller banks, and these institutions may have little or no connection to the communities that they serve. As a result, some banks are even more aggressive than they were before when it comes to collecting debts, and they do not hesitate to take adverse action like repossession, foreclosure, lawsuits, and harassment.

Moreover, in June 2017’s Henson v. Santander, a unanimous Court relaxed the rules even further, so moneylenders, and specifically debt buyers, may push the envelope even more in the coming months and years. Typically, moneylenders launch adverse action after two or three missed payments, and once the debt collection machine kicks into high gear, it is almost impossible to slow it down simply by making payments.

Fortunately, bankruptcy’s automatic stay offers a solution. In most cases, moneylenders cannot take any adverse action against debtors, even if that action is already pending, while the case is open, unless the bankruptcy judge grants special permission. Even if a foreclosure sale is scheduled for the afternoon, the automatic stay will usually stop it if the voluntary petition is filed in the morning.

Why People File Bankruptcy

Just like business downturn usually triggers the inability to pay business debts, financial storms that the debtor cannot possibly control usually lead to the inability to pay personal debts and therefore a Chapter 7 or Chapter 13 petition. Some of these events include:

  • – Medical Bills: Even if the debtor has good health insurance, the deductibles and copays associated with a serious illness are usually thousands of dollars, and neither hospitals nor banks are very patient when it comes to payment.
  • – Unemployment: Almost 70 percent of American families have less than $1,000 in savings, so even a temporary layoff usually has devastating consequences.
  • – Divorce: The unexpected legal fees, coupled with support payments and/or the expense involved in maintaining two households, triggers many bankruptcy filings.

Even if families can weather one of these storms, these events often come in pairs or in quick succession, and that is enough to swamp most any boat.

They say lightning never strikes twice in the same place, but there is no guarantee when it comes to financial storms. So, people can usually file bankruptcy again, after a short waiting period expires.

Go With Tenacious Attorneys

Most of the people who file bankruptcy are victims of adverse financial circumstances that they cannot control. For a free consultation with an experienced bankruptcy attorney in Chicago, contact the Bentz Holguin Law Firm, LLC. Convenient payment plans are available.

Resources:

thefirearmblog.com/blog/2017/07/30/d-k-arms-files-chapter-11-bankruptcy/

supremecourt.gov/opinions/16pdf/16-349_c07d.pdf

Bankruptcy And Consumer Credit Reports

Posted on: September 11, 2017 by in Bankruptcy
No Comments

TransUnion and Equifax Information Services violated the Fair Credit Reporting Act by posting erroneous information on a post-bankruptcy credit report, according to court documents filed in an Illinois federal court.

Mary Ahlers, of East St. Louis, says that the credit reporting companies recorded some debts as delinquent, as opposed to discharged, even after she received a debt forgiveness order that applied to the listed accounts. She blames the companies for not performing a diligent investigation, and then for not deleting or modifying the account data in light of the available information about the accounts. Her lawsuit demands compensation for unspecified out-of-pocket expenses and emotional distress.

Her lawsuit also seeks a court order that forces the companies to amend her credit reports.

How Does Bankruptcy Affect Credit Scores?

The answer to this question surprises many people, because in many cases, a bankruptcy looks better than long-term debt delinquency or adverse actions, like foreclosure or repossession. These negative reports are signals to many moneylenders that the debtor simply gave up and made no effort whatsoever to rectify the situation, and typically, that is probably a fair assessment.

However, if a consumer files bankruptcy, some moneylenders may conclude that something is better than nothing, and at least the debtor made some effort to cure the money problems. This is the same reason that a Chapter 13 (seven years) falls off most credit reports faster than a Chapter 7 (ten years).

As for the information on the credit report, it is often incumbent on the consumer to ensure that the data is accurate and that all discharged debts are listed as such, because as discussed in a previous post, the Supreme Court recently sided with a debt buyer against a consumer. So, it is fair to speculate that courts will show little interest in enforcing the FCRA and other consumer-friendly laws.

Managing Post-Bankruptcy Credit

Remaining current on any remaining secured debts, such as auto loans or home mortgages, is one of the best and fastest way to rebuild credit.

A new credit card may be a good idea as well, as long as it has a low credit line. If possible, obtain a secured card that does not contain a “secured” note on your credit report. Opinions vary as to whether it is best to pay off the entire balance each month to show diligent payment  or carry over a few dollars and allow the bank to make money.

A proactive attitude may be the best way to rebuild credit. Be upfront with future potential moneylenders about your past credit problems, and while they do not need or want to know details, they do need to hear a brief explanation for your filing, such as medical bills or whatever.

Debtors who keep true to these principles, and others that their attorneys suggest, are in the fast lane to credit restoration, while debtors that overlook or ignore them often end up back in bankruptcy court.

Reach Out to Experienced Attorneys

Effective credit recovery is part of a bankruptcy strategy. For a free consultation with an experienced bankruptcy attorney in Chicago, contact the Bentz Holguin Law Firm, LLC. Convenient payment plans are available.

Resource:

madisonrecord.com/stories/511146223-woman-alleges-inaccurate-credit-reporting-following-bankruptcy

Bankruptcy Filings Dip Slightly

Posted on: September 6, 2017 by in Bankruptcy, chapter 13, chapter 7
No Comments

According to the latest government statistics, distressed debtors have less money, owe less money, and are filing fewer voluntary bankruptcy petitions than they were a year ago.

Nationally, consumer filings dropped 6 percent in the latest filing tally. The average debtor had a $2,668 monthly income to pay $2,590 in monthly expenses. In 2015, both these figures were about 7 percent higher.

In Indiana, bankruptcy filings fell by 9 percent.

Types of Consumer Bankruptcy

Chapter 7 bankruptcy is normally a good option for families who owe more than $10,000 in unsecured debt, because that is realistically more money than most people can afford to repay. The list of dischargeable obligations includes:

  • Medical Bills: Even with health insurance, medical bills often overwhelm a family, which is why these expenses are one of the leading causes of bankruptcy.
  • Credit Cards: Like payday loans, credit cards are secured only by a future promise to pay, which is why credit card debt is one of the most frequently-discharged obligations.
  • Back Taxes: Income taxes are dischargeable if the taxpayer did not commit fraud or tax evasion, the tax is at least three years old, the returns have been on file at least two years, and the debt has not been assessed in the last 240 days.
  • Small Business Administration Loans: Most businesses fail within their first few years, and if your business is no longer in operation but the SBA loan is still outstanding, bankruptcy should be a consideration.

Bankruptcy eliminates the debt but not the collateral consequences of debt. So for example, if a taxing authority has filed liens on outstanding taxes, those liens remain even if the underlying debt is discharged.

Procedurally, after the debtor takes a debt counselling class, an attorney files a petition and schedules. About six weeks later, the debtor meets with the trustee (person who oversees the bankruptcy on behalf of the judge) to review the paperwork, and about six months after that, the judge typically signs the discharge order.

Chapter 7 debtors must pass the means test, which means their income must be lower than the average income for that geographic area.

In Chapter 13 cases, the debtor’s income usually needs to be slightly above average, since the debtor must make monthly debt consolidation payments. The debtor has up to five years to pay any arrearage on home mortgages, auto loans, and other secured debts.

The trustee also has a different role in Chapter 13 cases, because instead of simply reviewing paperwork, the trustee evaluates the debtor’s monthly income and expenses. The debtor ten remits any excess income as the debt consolidation payment.

Chapter 13 is a good option for people who are more than a month or two behind on secured debts.

Benefits of Bankruptcy

The automatic stay is one of the most significant benefits of bankruptcy. In most cases, moneylenders cannot take any adverse action against debtors as long as the case is pending. That includes lawsuits, repossessions, foreclosures, and collection phone calls.

Chapter 7 debtors receive a fresh financial start in only a few months, and Chapter 13 debtors have up to five years to pay off any arrearage. Furthermore, Chapter 13 debtors may also be eligible for cramdowns, which means that their secured loans are reduced to the current fair market value of the secured property.

Rely On Experienced Attorneys

Chapter 7 and Chapter 13 are the two main types of consumer bankruptcy. For a free consultation with an experienced bankruptcy attorney in Chicago, contact the Bentz Holguin Law Firm, LLC. We routinely handle matters in both Illinois and Indiana.

Resource:

ibj.com/articles/64552-indiana-bankruptcy-filings-take-downward-turn

Casino Remains On Track To Exit Bankruptcy

Posted on: August 30, 2017 by in Bankruptcy, chapter 13
No Comments

In much the same way that consumers deal with debts in a Chapter 13 bankruptcy, Caesars Entertainment Corporation hopes that Chapter 11 will give it a fresh start.

The company announced that about 90 percent of shareholders approved a merger between Caesars Entertainment Corporation, the bankrupt entity, and Caesars Acquisition Company. The merger is part of the company’s reorganization plan, which the shareholders must approve before the company can emerge from bankruptcy. In the coming months, regulators from both Nevada and Missouri will further scrutinize the plan, which is part of an action pending in an Illinois federal court.

Caesars CEO Mark Frissora said the merger “is an important milestone” in the case.

Renegotiating Debt

In many Chapter 13s, home mortgage debt is the largest single liability. Largely depending on the jurisdiction and the facts of the case, debtors may have some options in terms of renegotiating this and other secured debt.

One option may be a cramdown. Assume the homeowner recently purchased a $200,000 home and still owes $200,000 on the note. Further assume that the house’s tax appraised value is now $180,000. If that is the case, the actual fair market value may be even lower than that. Under these facts, the homeowner may be able to renegotiate the $200,000 unpaid principal balance down to $180,000, or the fair market value of the property. In this scenario, the additional $20,000 is forgiven.

A lien strip may be a possibility as well. Assume the homeowner took out a second mortgage for $20,000. If there is not enough equity in the property to secure both debts, the junior lien arguably becomes unsecured and therefore subject to discharge.

Finally, there may be a legitimate dispute as to the amount owed, perhaps because the loan was predatory or the homeowner may be eligible for a loan modification. In these cases, the judge usually refers the dispute to mediation, where the lender has a duty to negotiate in good faith. In other words, the moneylender must come down on its demand and try very hard to meet the homeowner somewhere in the middle.

Paying Off Debt

The principle advantage of a Chapter 13 is not the possibility for debt renegotiation, but the certainty of debt repayment. Debtors have up the five years to catch up on any delinquencies on any secured debt, including home mortgages and auto loans. During this period, the automatic stay remains in effect, in most cases, so moneylenders cannot take adverse action against the debtors, including repossession or foreclosure.

The repayment schedule is income-based, so debtors pay what they can afford as opposed to what the moneylender demands. Again in most cases, the moneylender cannot successfully oppose the repayment plan as long as the arrearage is satisfied within the protected repayment period.

Go With Experienced Attorneys

Chapter 13 debtors may have several debt reduction and debt repayment options. For a free consultation with an experienced bankruptcy attorney in Chicago, contact the Bentz Holguin Law Firm, LLC. We routinely handle cases in Illinois and Indiana.

Resource:

reviewjournal.com/business/casinos-gaming/caesars-shareholders-take-new-steps-to-emerge-from-bankruptcy/

Post-Filing Activity In An Illinois Bankruptcy

Posted on: August 21, 2017 by in Bankruptcy
No Comments

Nearly five years after the buy-sell-trade company filed bankruptcy, the trustee is still seizing and selling THR’s assets.

After locating a 2001 Chevrolet Suburban that belonged to the bankrupt company, the trustee almost immediately filed a motion to sell it at auction. Various state and federal agencies hold millions of dollars in liens against THR, and persistent allegations of bankruptcy fraud have kept the case open all this time. All told, the trustee has sold assets totalling $1.3 million to satisfy claims that exceed $57 million. Several years ago, the trustee seized a large number of collectibles and sold them at auction, including a New York State Prison electric chair, silver baby rattles, Elvis memorabilia, an armored van, and many other items.

THR acquired these items in its capacity as a reseller, and still had them when it ceased operations.

Seizing and Selling Assets

In corporate bankruptcies, the trustee is usually more aggressive in this area, because the intent of the Bankruptcy Code, which is to give the honest yet unfortunate debtor a fresh start, is not as applicable.

The trustee (individual who oversees a bankruptcy for the bankruptcy judge) has a duty to examine the debtor’s nonexempt assets and determine if selling them would be in the best interest of the creditors; the trustee does not have a duty to take everything possible and liquidate it, even in a Chapter 7.

Motor vehicles are a good example. Individual debtors in Illinois may exempt one vehicle with a value of up to $1,200. Bear in mind that this is the amount of equity in the vehicle, which is usually not the same as its fair market value.

Typically, new vehicles have high values but either little equity or, more likely, negative equity. On the flip side, older vehicles, like a 2001 SUV, usually have no outstanding loans but their fair market value is very low.

Assume the 2001 Suburban has a fair market value of $3,000. At the trustee’s recommendation, the judge could order the debtor to turn over the vehicle to the trustee for sale. After the trustee gave the debtor $1,200, the remaining $1,800 would be distributed among the creditors. However, the trustee must bear all the risk of sale, including towing costs, storage costs, make-ready expenses, any necessary repairs, auction costs, and all other expenses. Furthermore, there is no guarantee that the vehicle would sell for fair market value.

Therefore, when all is said and done, seizing this Suburban may likely result in a debt to the bankruptcy estate instead of a credit, or at best, a few dollars for each creditor, because proceeds must typically be distributed equally. Either result is arguably not in the best interest of the creditors.

Connect With Experienced Attorneys

Even if some of the debtor’s property is not exempt, the trustee will probably not seize it. For a free consultation with an experienced bankruptcy attorney in Chicago, contact the Bentz Holguin Law Firm, LLC. Convenient payment plans are available.

Resources:

sj-r.com/news/20170703/pieces-of-jeff-parsons-company-assets-continue-to-surface

kentlaw.edu/faculty/hchapman/classes/!%20FWMF07/!%20chapter%2010%20HANDOUTS.pdf

Prompted By Defective Airbag Imbroglio, Takata Files Bankruptcy

Posted on: August 8, 2017 by in Bankruptcy, chapter 11, chapter 13
No Comments

The Japanese manufacturer, which faces up to $24 billion in liability lawsuits, filed Chapter 11 Bankruptcy and said that its assets would be sold to a Chinese-led group. Attorneys for the Japanese manufacturer are probably hoping for a cramdown, a tool that’s also available in many consumer bankruptcies.

Historically, Chapter 11 proceedings that also involve possible negligence lawsuits, such as the 1995 Dow Corning bankruptcy, a company that faced billions of dollars in lawsuits related to defective breast implants, take years to complete. Furthermore, the government usually requires the bankrupt companies to set up large victim compensation trust funds. The Takata bankruptcy is even more complex both because of its size (the largest Japanese manufacturer ever to file bankruptcy) and the fact that, although the company has known about the defective airbag issue since at least 2004, no one knows the full extent of the company’s liability.

Takata confidently predicted that both the bankruptcy and the sale would be concluded by the first quarter 2018.

Chapter 13 Cramdowns

After several consecutive quarters of steady decline, the number of underwater mortgages (homeowners who owe more on their mortgages than their property is worth) inched up to 5.5 million nationwide. This figure only includes those properties that ATTOM Data Solutions, the private company which prepared the report, to be “seriously” underwater.

Since refinancing is normally not an option if the property will not appraise for greater than the requested loan value, bankruptcy is usually the best choice for distressed homeowners, if the bank is threatening to foreclose.

In a cramdown, any outstanding loan balance is reduced to match the collateral current market value. So, if Hank Homeowner owes $200,000 on a house that is only worth $180,000, a bankruptcy attorney can reduce his outstanding loan balance by $20,000, which will most likely be enough to bring Hank current on his payments.

A property’s as-is cash value, which must be listed on Schedule A per the Bankruptcy Code, may be as little as 50 percent of the tax appraisal value, because that’s the amount that a home investor would most likely pay in an as-is cash transaction. While this amount is often only a starting point in cramdown negotiations between a debtor and a lender, the potential savings could nevertheless be quite significant.

The same principle applies to other secured property, such as boats, cars, furniture, and anything else with a security agreement.

Chapter 13 debtors have up to five years to catch up on past-due secured debt payments while under the full protection of the bankruptcy court, and at the end of the protected repayment period, any remaining unsecured debts, like medical bills and credit cards, are completely discharged.

Connect With Experienced Attorneys

Many distressed homeowners can find long-term financial relief through bankruptcy. For a free consultation with an experienced bankruptcy attorney in Chicago, contact the Bentz Holguin Law Firm, LLC. Convenient payment plans are available.

Resources:

bloomberg.com/gadfly/articles/2017-06-26/takata-s-long-road-through-bankruptcy

washingtonpost.com/blogs/where-we-live/post/selling-a-home-to-a-real-estate-investor/2012/12/11/5907944e-40bb-11e2-a2d9-822f58ac9fd5_blog.html?utm_term=.2236831abf2a